An Epidemic of Fraud: MEF Expert Exposes Corruption in Human Rights Organizations

Winfield Myers

Michael Rubin, director of policy analysis at the Middle East Forum.

PHILADELPHIA, June 17, 2024 – Michael Rubin, director of policy analysis for the Middle East Forum, testified before the Tom Lantos Human Rights Commission of the U.S. House of Representatives on June 13, 2024, about the growing problem of human rights fraud perpetrated by major organizations.

Rubin testified that

human rights fraud is epidemic. While boutique human rights organizations might promote and profit from shoddy if not dishonest advocacy, marquee organizations like Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch increasingly trade upon reputations built in decades past to cover or give credence to fraudulent work today.

When the U.S. ambassador to the United Nations ignores fraud, waste, and abuse in U.N. agencies, she enables it. To advocate for a clean U.N. by demanding the organization clean house is not anti-U.N. After all, should the U.S. ambassador fight corruption in Mexico, no honest analyst would dismiss this as anti-Mexican.

While many human rights advocates and researchers demand governments and media take their findings at face value, increasingly political and profit motivations undercut their work. An unprecedented crisis afflicts human rights organizations today, made worse by their tendency to circle the wagons, demonize critics, and deflect criticism rather than acknowledge and weed out rot.

Rubin went on to detail three major types of human rights fraud: corruption of methodology, outright falsehood, and pay-to-play schemes.

“Michael Rubin’s exposure of the rot within major human rights organizations should be taken seriously by taxpayers, legislators, and anyone concerned with promoting human rights instead of bureaucrats’ careers,” said Middle East Forum director Gregg Roman. “Policymakers and the public must demand full transparency and accountability from groups that have strayed from their founding missions in pursuit of money and political agendas.”


The Middle East Forum, a non-profit organization, promotes American interests in the Middle East and protects Western civilization from Islamism. It does so through a combination of original ideas, focused activism, and funding allies. For more information, visit www.meforum.org.

For immediate release
For more information, contact:
Gregg Roman
roman@meforum.org
+1 (215) 546 5406

See more on this Topic
PHILADELPHIA – August 20, 2024 – A member of Maryland’s “Commission on Hate Crimes Response and Prevention” is out of a job. Ayman Nassar, the second Islamist commissioner to get tossed from the hate crimes board within three months, resigned on August 19 amid public outrage over his role in terror-linked organizations and his history of anti-American, antisemitic, and homophobic hate speech.

Nassar has accused Israel of harvesting the organs of living Palestinians and shared posts referring to Gaza as a “Holocaust.” He is chairman of the Aafia Foundation, a “terrorist support group” that seeks to free “Lady Al Qaeda” Aafia Siddiqui and other convicted terrorists from prison.
PHILADELPHIA – July 31, 2024 – Hours after Israel assassinated two leading figures of designated terrorist organizations, Middle East Forum (MEF) experts took to major media outlets to explain what the killings mean for Israel and the region.

Israeli forces killed Hezbollah leader Fouad Shukur in Beirut on Tuesday, while Hamas leader Ismail Haniyeh died Wednesday from an Israeli strike in Tehran. Both men caused the deaths of innocent civilians as well as Israeli and American soldiers.

Writing today for the Wall Street Journal, MEF president Daniel Pipes argued that since Hamas’s Oct. 7 attacks, Israel has unfortunately followed “two opposite policies” simultaneously: “destroy the organization and make a deal with it.”