Israeli Arabs in Germany Spoke about Hamas as a Terrorist Organization

Winfield Myers

A delegation of Israeli Arabs from the NGO Atidna spent eleven days in December in Germany raising awareness about Hamas as a terrorist movement and the values of a multi-religious democratic Jewish state.

Atidna—a word that combines Arabic and Hebrew to mean “our future"—is an innovative grassroots organization that seeks to build a “partnership with Arabs and Jews” who view themselves as citizens of a “democratic and Jewish state,” Amit Deri, the CEO Partner of Atidna, told the Jerusalem Post.

The twenty-person delegation, organized their annual trip to Germany before the October 7 war and decided not to cancel it due to the pressing need to explain the nature of the Hamas terrorist movement.

Speaking with the Post from Germany on Thursday, Etaf Shtewe, the Israeli-Arab project and community manager for Atidna, said Atidna members were “wearing shirts of the organization with Hebrew and the Israeli flag” in public.

She said “people were really interested and asking questions.” One question was: “What is your position on the war?”

Shtewe said the group told Germans “About Hamas as a terrorist” organization.

The delegation, Shetwe stressed, told the Germans they met that “They are Arabs and proud of who they are and to be part of Israel.”

There was resistance from German Arabs in Berlin, Shetwe said. Many German Arabs rejected Atidna’s mission and are “against the existence of the State of Israel.”

German Cities See Increase in Rallies, Demonstrations Since Start of War

A number of large German cities, including the capital Berlin, saw mass rallies and demonstrations since the outbreak of the war filled with antisemitic slogans calling for the destruction of the Jewish state and expressing support for Hamas.

In response to attempts by some German Arabs to reduce Israeli Arabs to Palestinians, the Atidna delegation rejected the one-dimensional approach and “insisted on their position” as “citizens of Israel who are very proud of it.”

Atidna met with Israeli diplomats at the embassy and German politicians and educators. Suleiman Suleiman, the second CEO Partner of Atidna, told the Post, “We had a demonstration in front of the Brandenburg Gate and told them we are against Hamas and terror. We are not just saying things but want people to know.We stand behind Israel. We have Arab-Christians with us. We are proud to be Israelis.”

He said people on the street had mixed reactions to their views. Some anti-Israel Germans said “There is no country in the word called Israel. I had to explain there are Arabs in Israel. If you don’t want to accept Israel, that is your problem.”

Suleiman continued to spar against the anti-Israel hate from some Germans, stating “How can you support Hamas , I asked. They asked how can we support Israel.”

He termed the experience as “Small aggressive reactions, but, on the other hand, found people who did not know there were Arabs in Israel.”

Suleiman said the delegation met with a school teacher in the largely German Muslim district of Neukölln, where some of the most intense pro-Hamas demonstrations unfolded. “Suleiman said the group spoke with an " Iraqi-born teacher who was in Israel and is pro-Israel” and teaches at a school at Neukölln.

The delegation was also exposed to Germany’s history. “We do education youth exchanges every year. German partners host us and we are learning about the Holocaust and the history of Berlin and Germany. Our German partners come to Israel every year and live with families.”

Ali Nujidat told the Post “I went to the delegation straight from the reserves. People were interested” in Atidna. He said he explained to Germans that Atidna works to “integrate Arabs into Israeli society.”

“A lot of people asked us questions on the street. The most interesting community was the Arab community. An Iraqi studied in the US and was the first to sign the petition against the actions of Hamas.”

The Iraqi is the teacher in the Neukölln district of Berlin.

Deri established Atidna with the late Dr. Dalia Fadila five years ago. He said Atidna works with more than 30 municipalities across Israel and has more than 5,000 Israeli-Arab youths enrolled in the NGO’s program.

He noted that Atidna has a “Leadership academy to prepare them be citizens in life of Israel” and a works in Israel’s storied high-tech sector to find “workplace for Israel-Arabs to integrate them into high-tech jobs. " Atidna partners with the ministry of science.

Benjamin Weinthal, a Ginsburg/Milstein Writing Fellow at the Middle East Forum, reports on Israel, Iran, Syria, Turkey and Europe for Fox News Digital. Follow him on Twitter at @BenWeinthal.

Benjamin Weinthal is an investigative journalist and a Writing Fellow at the Middle East Forum. He is based in Jerusalem and reports on the Middle East for Fox News Digital and the Jerusalem Post. He earned his B.A. from New York University and holds a M.Phil. from the University of Cambridge. Weinthal’s commentary has appeared in the Wall Street Journal, Haaretz, the Guardian, Politico, the New York Daily News, the New York Post, Ynet and many additional North American and European outlets. His 2011 Guardian article on the Arab revolt in Egypt, co-authored with Eric Lee, was published in the book The Arab Spring (2012).
See more from this Author
In Apparent Snub to U.S., Turkish Foreign Minister Says ‘Elimination’ of Group Is Country’s ‘Strategic Goal’
Hamas’s Penetration of UNRWA Means the Terror Group Hijacks Supplies the Aid Organization Says It Delivers
Berlin-based Al-Mustafa Institute a Branch of School that Recruits for IRGC
See more on this Topic
I recently witnessed something I haven’t seen in a long time. On Friday, August 16, 2024, a group of pro-Hamas activists packed up their signs and went home in the face of spirited and non-violent opposition from a coalition of pro-American Iranians and American Jews. The last time I saw anything like that happen was in 2006 or 2007, when I led a crowd of Israel supporters in chants in order to silence a heckler standing on the sidewalk near the town common in Amherst, Massachusetts. The ridicule was enough to prompt him and his fellow anti-Israel activists to walk away, as we cheered their departure. It was glorious.