The Great Pager Detonation: The End of Phones and Computers on Airplanes?

The Ramifications of the Attack, However Warranted It Was, Go Far Beyond the Middle East

The question for security experts is whether the operation presumably carried out against Hezbollah pagers could be replicated on American or European cell phones or other electronic equipment.

Shutterstock

Is “Operation Below the Belt” the End of Phones and Computers on Airplanes? Earlier today, some entity—presumably Israel—caused 3,000 pagers used by Hezbollah to detonate simultaneously.

It was a unique operation and demonstrated both Israel’s technological capabilities as well as its penetration of Hezbollah and Iranian networks.

After all, Iran supplied the pagers to Hezbollah just a few months ago.

The ramifications of the attack, however warranted it was, go far beyond the Middle East, however.

Hezbollah might have been today’s target, but today’s events may have the most profound impact on the aviation industry since 9/11.

Wifi has become the norm on passenger planes. Whereas airlines once banned Samsung phones due to questions about their safety after reports that they overheated and still do not allow shipment of lithium batteries in the cargo hold, most passengers today bring laptops, cell phones, and tablets onboard flights.

Indeed, on most American aircraft, access to the entertainment system requires the passenger to use his phone, tablet, or computer.

The question for security experts—and certainly one on which Al Qaeda now works—is whether the operation presumably carried out against Hezbollah pagers could be replicated on American or European cell phones or other electronic equipment.

Put another way, who needs box cutters or an underwear bomb to bring down an aircraft if a signal could overheat, if not detonate, a couple hundred tablets or phones at 30,000 feet above the Atlantic?

For 23 years, air travelers have had to limit their liquids and submit to vigorous pat-downs as the Transportation Security Agency or its European corollaries sought to protect travelers against the tactics of a past attack.

Today’s demonstration in Lebanon should raise red flags: Are water bottles or computers the greater threat? Do computers or phones have to be on to receive the signal that causes detonation? If not, will airlines ever accept such electronics in carry-on or cargo? If Wi-Fi is necessary to transmit the signal, is that the end of Wi-Fi on flights? And if passengers cannot do work on an aircraft, will they even fly or turn to video conferencing?

Hezbollah might have been today’s target, but today’s events may have the most profound impact on the aviation industry since 9/11.

Michael Rubin is a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, where he specializes in Middle Eastern countries, particularly Iran and Turkey. His career includes time as a Pentagon official, with field experiences in Iran, Yemen, and Iraq, as well as engagements with the Taliban prior to 9/11. Mr. Rubin has also contributed to military education, teaching U.S. Navy and Marine units about regional conflicts and terrorism. His scholarly work includes several key publications, such as “Dancing with the Devil” and “Eternal Iran.” Rubin earned his Ph.D. and M.A. in history and a B.S. in biology from Yale University.
See more from this Author
The Supreme Leader’s Son Does Not Have the Prestige of Iran’s Grand Ayatollahs or Even Many Ordinary Ayatollahs
U.S. Policymakers Should Know That Not All Factions Are Equal in Yemen’s Presidential Leadership Council
The Kingdom Does Not like the Houthis, but Long Ago Stopped Seeking to Win the War Against Them
See more on this Topic
MBS Sharpened His Criticism of Israel and Continues to Warm Ties with Iran, but a Defense Pact with the U.S. Is Still His Priority and Tehran Is Still the Chief Foe
Turkish Authorities Face Criticism for Releasing a Radical Kurdish Cleric Linked to ISIS, Allowing Him to Resume Preaching and Recruiting for Jihadist Networks Across Turkey and Georgia
Critics of Islam in 2024 Europe Face Repression Akin to the Treatment of Anti-soviet Writers in the 1950s—Silenced with Fear and Police at the Door.