Middle East Quarterly

Spring 1999

Volume 6: Number 2

Building Towards Crisis

Saddam Husayn’s Strategy for Survival

Book Reviews:

Iraq Strategy Review: Options for U.S. Policy
Edited by Patrick L. Clawson. Washington, D.C.: The Washington Institute for Near East Policy, 1998. 181 pp. $16.95 (paper).

Baram’s long essay offers a wealth of little-known information and a shrewd assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of Saddam Husayn’s regime, based on the author’s encyclopedic knowledge of the Iraqi political and tribal elite and the complex relationships within the president’s own extended family. Baram finds that although the regime has been weakened by internal division, defections (especially of Husayn Kamil) and family feuds, its leader’s capacity to hold on to power remains largely unshaken. “As long as it is not committed explicitly and decisively to the ouster of the Iraqi President, the international community should not be surprised to see itself further manipulated to suit Saddam Husayn’s purposes.” His general conclusion is bleak: although weakened, Saddam Husayn is as firmly entrenched as ever, and those opposing him, nationally, regionally and internationally, are weaker and more divided than they were in 1991.

Contributors to Clawson’s edited volume examine six policy options for the United States: (1) pursuing a narrower form of containment; (2) limiting action against the Iraqi regime to occasions when the regime attacks its neighbors; (3) continuing present policies; (4) supporting the opposition to weaken Saddam Husayn; (5) assisting the opposition to bring down the regime and take over power for itself; (6) full-scale U.S. invasion leading to an ouster of the regime. The authors present arguments for and against each of these courses of action, without drawing general conclusions.

Both short books offer a useful guide to current realities, but neither addresses a key problem: the evident U.S. inability to keep the anti-Saddam coalition up to the mark, both regionally and internationally. Why on earth, I cannot help thinking—and as I thought at the time—was General Schwarzkopf ordered not to push on to Baghdad in 1991?

Amatzia Baram is a professor emeritus of Middle East history at University of Haifa. During his tenure there, he served as chairman of the Department of Middle East History, director of the Jewish-Arab Center and the Institute for Middle East Studies, and founder and head of the Center for Iraq Studies. He advised the U.S. government on Iraq under Presidents Reagan, Bush, Clinton, Bush, and Obama. Baram has published six books, some 80 articles in academic journals, and numerous articles in newspapers such as the New York Times and the Washington Post. Presently, he is a regular contributor to Geopolitical Intelligence Services (GIS), published by Prince Michael of Liechtenstein.
See more from this Author
After Iran’s Second Strong Strike on Israel, Jerusalem’s Response, the Fate of Hezbollah, and Preserving Iran’s Oil Exports Will Determine Tehran’s Strategy
The Stances of the Dual Leaderships in Beirut and Tehran Suggest That the Recent Events Will Not Propel Hezbollah and Iran Into a Full-Scale Conflict
See more on this Topic